Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 6, 2008

Memo to Obama Campaign & Surrogates

How not to respond to McCain attack memes:

  1. Claim, as does Bob Herbert, that McCain's "Celebrity" ad deliberately juxtaposed Britney Spears with 'phallic' imagery like the Leaning Tower of Pisa and the Washington Monument to inflame subconscious fears of interracial sex.
  2. Suggest, as does Timothy Noah in Slate, that the WSJ's article on Obama's skinniness is really about his race.
  3. Opine, as does The One himself, that the political party that represents about 50% of the nation "takes pride in being ignorant."
How to respond to McCain attack memes:
  1. Point out that McCain himself now concedes that inflating your tires is a good idea.
  2. Circulate widely the news that Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, potential dark-horse McCain VP pick, supports Obama's energy plan. (Question: is she now off the shortlist because she endorsed Obama's plan, or is it the other way around? Discuss.)
  3. Somehow get the most loathed celebrity in America, and the daughter of a major McCain supporter, to release the best political ad of the season so far:
  4. . . . and don't let the McCain camp somehow claim that Ms. Hilton's energy plan is the GOP plan, when in fact it's nearly identical to your own.
The October Protocol will see you at the debates, bitches.

Read More...

Monday, August 4, 2008

Baseless VP speculation

Now who knows what this means, but for shits and giggles I typed in the following web addresses today:

www.obamakaine08.com

www.obamasebelius08.com

www.obamaclinton08.com

www.obamabayh08.com

. . . and only one of them links directly to the Democratic Party's website.

If it's true, color me disappointed.

UPDATE: Koan gets totally pwned by his lack of knowledge about who owns website names. Oh well.

The October Protocol is sick of waiting and wants to fucking know already.

Read More...

Saturday, August 2, 2008

Campaign Appearances: July Update



We first ran this piece last month and here is the line graph with the July totals included. At first glance the July numbers seem to fit with the earlier numbers - both candidates scaled back the number of domestic appearances this month. A closer inspection reveals that Sen. Obama is dominating Sen. McCain on the summer trail. Obama's excuse for the decline in his July appearance numbers was he was part of a hugely successful week-long CODEL trip to Europe and the Middle East. McCain's excuse was . . . well . . . hey, he's 71, it's summertime, you know what that means . . . GOLF CARTS MUTHAFUCKA!



Despite Obama playing Paris Hilton to hundreds of thousands of German "fans" he still managed to outcampaign McCain back in the states by a 29-18 campaign event margin in July. Must have been all of those Met-RX energy bars, or the Black Forest Berry Honest Tea, or maybe it's his freakishly skinny physique. McCain better be careful in August, he might get lapped by the hardest working man in show business.

The Protocol always travels fast, hard, and low to the ground.

Read More...

Florida Front Pages

Yesterday was a big day for the Sunshine State. Both candidates were campaigning in Florida with Sen. Obama visiting the Bay Area and Sen. McCain in Orlando. Sen. Obama was heckled at his town hall meeting in St. Petersberg by members of the International People's Democratic Uhuru Movement, a pan-African Socialist group. (The Obama campaign responded by thanking the group and blasting undecided voters inboxes with a memo titled, "Jesse's not the only one: More lefty black folks that hate me.") Meanwhile, McCain yukked it up with National Urban League in an attempt to cut into Obama's base.

The visits also happened to coincide with a report that Florida is in a recession for the first time in 16 years.

Ambinder speculated about whether today's Florida headlines would focus on economics or race and that a move in one direction would indicate whether the "race card" attack was taking hold.

The Protocol looked at today's front pages of the top five Florida newspapers (by circulation) and is ready to deliver a verdict . . .



St. Petersburg Times circ. 422,410
The Times leads with "Obama open to drilling" with a large picture of him smiling among supporters. The picture of Obama dominates a smaller picture of McCain joking with National Urban League President Marc Morial. With economics front and center particularly Obama's move toward drilling, an issue that the McCain campaign wanted to wedge between the two candidates, this front page is favorable to the Democrat. Papers commonly give favorable coverage to any visiting candidate and that phenomenon is borne out by the contrasting front pages of the St. Pete Times and the Orlando Sentinel. Obama's visit focused on the Bay Area and McCain's centered on Orlando. ADVANTAGE OBAMA


Miami Herald circ. 390,171
The Herald provides equal visual coverage under the headline "Florida Showdown." In the article, however, the body starts with racial issues, hecklers included, and this after a lede that set up the economy before the racial issues ("...offering contrasting fixes for the economy while confronting racial issues"). That subtle mismatch smacks of an editor flipping the body paragraphs before going to press. Burying the economic news after the jump: ADVANTAGE MCCAIN


Orlando Sentinel circ. 341,025
The Sentinel headlines with "MCCAIN: OBAMA NOT BEST PICK FOR BLACKS," and a picture of Sen. McCain and National Urban League President Marc Morial having a good ole time onstage. If a picture is worth 1000 words, then this one is repeating "Playing the race card? Me? John McCain? How could I?" about a hundred times. Again, the soft coverage of McCain could be due to the fact that he was the candidate with a higher profile local visit. ADVANTAGE MCCAIN


South Florida Sun-Sentinel circ. 339,728
The Sun-Sentinel had nothing on the front page about the candidates save for a small photo of McCain at the bottom in the Daily Digest referring to reader mail about his rejected NYT editorial. Above the fold they ran a story on the aforementioned recession. They were the only paper on this list with that story on the front page and the only paper with no front-page story on the candidates. ADVANTAGE OBAMA



Tampa Tribune and Times circ. 309,916
The Tampa Tribune focuses on the battle and gives equal coverage to both candidates. There is no mention of race and the text highlights the main theme of each candidate's visit: Obama's economic stimulus plan and McCain's school vouchers strategy. While the issues and the economy trump race on this page the coverage seems even-handed. NO ADVANTAGE

Sooooo, that's two for Obama and two for McCain with one tie. Looks like both campaigns are getting their message out in equal measure. Keep an eye on those Sunday papers to see if there is any movement toward race or economics.

The Protocol always buries the lede below the fold.

Read More...

Friday, August 1, 2008

Professor Obama

The NYT ran a long feature Wednesday about the twelve years Barack Obama spent teaching law at the University of Chicago. The paper’s framing of the story is that Obama kept himself aloof from the Chicago faculty, made his political ambitions known, and shrewdly kept his positions on policy questions such as affirmative action and government regulation close to the chest.

“He surfaced all the competing points of view on [controversial quota-queen Lani] Guinier’s proposals with total neutrality and equanimity,” says Prof. David Franklin, sounding a familiar theme about Obama that he excels at dispassionate analysis, with a gift for empathizing with both sides of hot button issues. The flipside to this gift, of course, is that it leaves people heavily invested in academic and intellectual camps wondering whose side he’s really on.

My take on the article's portrait of Obama as a professor, and the insights that can be gleaned from his Constitutional Law exams and answer keys, is that they confirm my view of him as a thoughtful and careful legal mind more interested at getting at the heart of policy disputes than in resolving them. His course materials emphasize the realities of racism, disenfranchisement, and poverty--and the distortions those realities have on a democratic political process--while at the same time acknowledging the failures of heavy-handed attempts to fix them from the top down. One question from a 1996 exam asked students to analyze two hypothetical proposals by a black mayor, in a heavily segregated city split 50-50 between blacks and whites with a significant history of institutional racism in the power structure, to ensure that the awarding of construction contracts and the hiring of firemen better reflect the city's racial composition. Both proposals are facially race-neutral, with the construction proposal skewing toward companies based in low-income neighborhoods and the fireman proposal doing away with a (possibly culturally-biased) written exam.

Obama's answer key to both questions isn't earth-shattering: he's looking for students to analyze the right cases (Aderand, Croson, Washington v. Davis, etc.) and put forth good arguments about the level of scrutiny such proposals would face in court and the likelihood of surviving. What strikes me though is his understanding that it's not enough to believe that the mayor is right, or that his proposals are a good idea--you have to convince a court that the proposals play by the rules the Supreme Court has set down regarding discriminatory intent, narrow tailoring to a compelling state interest, and so forth. He seems keenly aware that knowing your arguments are the right ones is not enough in a sprawling, diverse democracy: you need to take seriously the opposing views, pare the issues down to their cores, search for the common ground, and move from there.

Lawyers are trained to be advocates, to take a goal (my client's best interest) and pursue any and all threads that lead to that goal while ignoring, minimizing, or attacking those that don't. Obama's not an advocate. He's a balancer. He doesn't make a stand and then use whatever arguments happen to be convenient to defend that stand til the crack of doom--he weighs competing sides, acknowledges the impossibility of always being right, and looks for common ground. So when Richard Epstein complains that "he’s always been a thoughtful listener and questioner, but he’s never stepped up to the plate and taken full swings," he means Obama's never planted his flag in the sands of an idea and loaded his guns to defend it, right or wrong.

Which is exactly what voters sick of pig-headed, reflexive partisanship find so refreshing.

By way of reflexive balance, the October Protocol notes the extensive use of the words "I" and "me" in Obama's memos and communications to his law classes.

Read More...

Thursday, July 31, 2008

Culture Wars Part III: The Turd Blossoms Again

Rick Davis, McCain's campaign manager, and Andrea Mitchell go toe to toe in this remarkable interview.

As Ambinder notes the action starts two and a half minutes in and continues right up till the end.

I wonder if this is the beginning of the end of the media's love affair with Sen. McCain. They've always appreciated his candor and his open-bus policy but this recent string of ads has shown that he, and Davis, are running Karl Rove's third presidential campaign.

The choice to align himself with Bush four years ago was McCain's critical mistake. Had he maintained his maverick persona, channeled the animosity he must have felt toward Bush/Rove and Co. after the South Carolina primary in 2000, he could have remained ever the straight talker, and run as a genuine alternative to the Bush White House. Instead he continues to follow the spirit of the hug by hiring a Rove lackey to run his day-to-day (Steve Schmidt) and allowing his campaign to continue to wage Rove's culture war.

The media has begun to realize that their proud maverick has become a puppet. John McCain might not lead the country like George W. Bush, but he is certainly campaigning like him. That would be a great plan, I mean, GW has won two in a row and if it ain't broke, . . . there must be nothing to fix, right?.

Read More...

Thursday, July 10, 2008

Obama v. McCain: Campaign Appearances by Month



McCain is averaging 34.2 campaign appearances per month since April 2007, while Obama is averaging 45.7 over that same time frame. This difference isn't THAT surprising considering Obama's extended primary vs. Sen. Clinton. Sen. Obama's primary season was four months longer than Sen. McCain's (Feb.-May), and Obama significantly outpaced McCain in appearances during those four months.

McCain's three lowest totals came in July and August of 2007, and March of 2008. The latter month was when he took his trip to Iraq so that can partially explain the lower number. In July of 07 the McCain campaign underwent its first major reshuffling, so those months could've been spent restrategizing. That and it was widely known that his campaign was low on funds, so he could've been husbanding resources during the August vacation period.

Obama's lowest months were April and May 2007, and, interestingly, March 2008. Two of these "low" months included more appearances than McCain's average month, so keep that in perspective. The early slower pace to his campaign schedule could have been attributed to a new campaign finding its bearings (and working with a smaller war chest). The March 08 number is notable since it came during the heart of his intense primary campaign. Perhaps he was taking a break, relatively speaking, after the 30 contests in February, or that less frequent primaries and caucuses meant fewer requirements for appearances.

McCain has the highest single month total, with 63 appearances in January 08, a statistic that supports the "John McCain: 71 years YOUNG" argument. This was the month he essentially clinched the nomination, so his 24 appearances in Florida and 16 each in Michigan and South Carolina make sense. He hasn't made half as many appearances in any month since this high month. He was campaigning much harder in May and June of '07 than he did in those same months in '08. A lot of that '07 work was probably fundraisers and other events to guarantee his fledgling candidacy's survival, but the relative inactivity of his campaign since January, especially recently, could haunt him as the general heats up.

There was less of a need to make appearances after had sewn up the nomination, but that argument makes sense for every month up until June. Both candidates total appearances came down in June but, while for Obama that makes sense, he finally could take a break from the trail after securing the nomination, McCain needed no such break. He had been relaxing and stretching his legs since January. Why didn't his campaign hit its stride in June and taken advantage of the Dems drawn-out fight?

Well, considering that McCain's campaign has undergone another July shake-up (in what is becoming an annual rite of passage), we now know that incompetence is partly to blame. Months that could've been used to define their candidate while the two Dems bloodied each other late into the spring were squandered. I'll be interested to see the trend of those campaign appearance totals as the general heats up in the fall. Will McCain start campaigning on weekends? Is his lower number of appearances somehow related to his age? The high total in January seems to indicate otherwise but perhaps he reacted poorly to those 60+ appearances? He certainly looked terrible on the trail in January, but a lot of that was his poor public speaking skills, which I've read have been coached out of him. While these questions about his age are speculative, McCain can put to bed some of these whispers with a robust slate of appearances in September.

That type of schedule would lend more credence to the argument that his absence on the trail in the spring was a strategic error, and not one of necessity given the Senator's age. Either way, with the depressed value of the Republican brand the McCain campaign has less margin for error than the typical Republican Presidential candidate. With his slow start on the trail in June, that margin may have already been breached.

The Protocol has evidence that Sen. McCain was replaced by a robot on the campaign trail in January.

Read More...

Obama v. McCain: Top 10 Campaign Stops



The NYT has a great interactive graphic that shows where the candidates have made appearances since April 2007. The Times defines appearances as speeches, fundraisers, meet and greets, debates, press avails, private events, and assorted other events. The two charts below show the ten cities each candidate has visited most frequently since they started campaigning last spring.

(The Protocol will be delivering more analysis of this data in the coming days...stay tuned.)




























































OBAMA's TOP 10
Rank City No. of Events
1 Des Moines, IA 33
2 Washington, DC 31
3 Chicago, IL 27
4 Las Vegas, NV 17
5 Los Angeles, CA 13
6 Manchester, NH 12
t7 Colombia, SC 10
t7 New York City, NY 10
9 Philadelphia, PA 9
10 Portland, OR 7









































































McCAIN's TOP 10
Rank City No. of Events
1 Washington, DC 19
t2 Manchester, NH 12
t2 New York City, NY 12
t4 Columbia, SC 11
t4 Miami, FL 11
6 Phoenix, AZ 10
t7 Concord, NH 9
t7 Des Moines, IA 9
9 Charleston, SC 8
t10 Chicago, IL 7
t10 Nashua, NH 7
t10 Orlando, FL 7

Read More...

Tuesday, July 8, 2008

No FARCing Shit

So, to nobody's real surprise, the U.S. military was apparently involved in last week's rescue of American hostages from everybody's favorite group of Colombian narco-terrorists. The story first broke courtesy of Al Giordano's The Field, a source I immediately distrusted because it egged on my natural inclination to find American military skullduggery everywhere without providing a shred of hard evidence. (Note to Al: a link to another blogger on your own semi-paranoid, pro-legalization site--and that to an article quoting a single, anonymous source--does not a convincing argument make.) My latte liberal sensibilities were assuaged, though, once the news of U.S. involvement made it to NPR. Whew! Now I can believe it!

Howver, Giordano's assertion that the raid was staged to help the political fortunes of John McCain struck me as too much of a stretch. Of course it makes perfect sense that the U.S. was involved in the operation, and I could even believe that Colombia's President Alvaro Uribe wants John McCain to win enough to lend a hand, even possibly inventing a FARC laptop clumsily connecting Obama to Hugo Chavez. Why, though, this little bit of stagecraft would help McCain is beyond me--it's not like what's being sold as a Colombian army operation has registered in any meaningful way with the great middle swath of the electorate he needs. Not to mention the fact that calling attention to his positions on trade probably won't help him with the blue-collar quasi-Clintonites he'll need in November.

Tinfoil hats cannot stop the rays of The October Protocol.

Read More...

Saturday, July 5, 2008

Pay them and they will come

There's a fairly interesting article in today's NYTimes about employers' reactions to the recent spate of immigration raids.

The article, written by the Times' immigration beat reporter, Julia Preston, dances around an issue that I think has garnered much too little attention: that employers, not workers, bear most of the responsibility for the "problem" of illegal immigration, as they're the ones driving the market forces that make it happen.

One of the most revealing passages appears early in the article:

Though the pushback is coming from both Democrats and Republicans, in many places it is reopening the rift over immigration that troubled the Republican Party last year. Businesses, generally Republican stalwarts, are standing up to others within the party who accuse them of undercutting border enforcement and jeopardizing American jobs by hiring illegal immigrants as cheap labor.

What is strangest about this is that it is the Nativist wing- in standard, MSM terms, the wingnuts- that, ostensibly carry the flag of anger over wage suppression, a legitimate, and, in some ways, liberal position.

I think this issue basically reveals the cynicism and selfishness of the major forces at work in the immigration debate. Employers, terrified of a cost to their bottom line, or even worse, being accused of actively soliciting undocumented employees, want either no enforcement of current laws or some sort of guest-worker program, a solution that would deliver a steady population of docile workers whose very right to stay in the country would depend on their bosses' say-so.

Employers could do the right thing-- campaign for amnesty and drastically increased legal immigration quotas-- but their standard-bearer Chamber of Commerce party, the GOP, just isn't willing to spend that kind of political capital.

As a side note, look how the employers, according to Preston, use the "market" to defend their position:

Mike Gilsdorf, the owner of a 37-year-old landscaping nursery in Littleton, Colo., saw the need for action by businesses last winter when he advertised with the Labor Department, as he does every year, for 40 seasonal workers at market-rate wages to plant, prune and carry his shrubs in the summer heat. Only one local worker responded to the notice, he said, and then did not show up for the job.

and then...

“I can’t replace those people,” the executive said. She said that despite offering competitive wages from $9 to $17 an hour, the company had failed over the years in repeated efforts to attract non-immigrant workers because of the state’s tight technology labor market and because of the nature of the work, exacting and tedious. If the workers were fired or arrested, she said, she could fail to meet her contracts.

What do terms like "market rate" and "competitive wages" mean in this context? Shouldn't "market rate" or "competitive" refer to the price you'd actually have to pay a legally protected employee to do a job? Why do we accept the employers' definition, which seems to be a Platonic notion of what they feel they ought to pay?

More later...

Read More...

Ain't no one gonna change my Jersey mind

I love posts like this that expose the hidden architecture of our political system. Who knew it was such a bear to run a modern presidential campaign in Jersey? Or Delaware?

But it does make me a little mad that Nate Silver is always so goddamn smart. Who does he think he is?

Read More...

Wednesday, July 2, 2008

A scandal to run with

You can be a peace-loving freedom warrior, and, because you're a little bit of a lefty, you get thrown on the terror watch list. But support batshit crazy right-wing terrorist death squads and no one really cares. This shit is mind-boggling.

The October Protocol does not fund international terrorist organizations or support the purchase and consumption of conflict bananas.

Read More...

Tuesday, July 1, 2008

A fun fact I learned today...

Over the past couple days, I've been doing preliminary reporting on a couple stories relating to immigration that I'm hoping to write this summer, and I've already stumbled across some harrowing facts about our jalopy of a national immigration system.

Did you know, for instance, that citizens from any country that has seen over 50,000 people immigrate to the U.S. in the last 5 years are forbidden from taking part in our visa lottery? (There are other ways to get in, but the lottery is the only one available to people without family connections, a highly marketable skill, or a documented case for asylum).

Excluded countries include Mexico, Canada, India, China, the Philippines, Korea, Vietnam, Pakistan, Colombia, El Salvador, Jamaica, Haiti, Russia, the UK and Poland, i.e. the world's two largest countries, the entire northern hemisphere, and most of our closest allies.

WTF?

This also means that when people say Mexican construction and agricultural workers should "just get in line," they are asking them to do something that is, in many cases...impossible.

Read More...

Monday, June 30, 2008

The Court Supreme and the Election

In the past two weeks, the Supreme Court handed down four decisions that could affect the dynamic and rhetoric of the Obama-McCain matchup. From the landmark Second Amendment ruling in D.C. v. Heller to the less-noticed tweaking of campaign finance law in Davis v. F.E.C., all four rulings broke from the Roberts Court's recent trend and reverted back to the five-to-four, liberal-v.-conservative bloc rulings of the past. Anthony Kennedy cemented his position as the new O'Connor-ite swing vote, Nino Scalia finally got to write a binding manifesto for the conservative movement, and Samuel Alito struck a blow for millionaires everywhere.

All four decisions broke 5-4, with the liberals (Stevens, Souter, Ginsburg, Breyer) opposing the conservatives (Scalia, Thomas, Roberts, Alito) and with Kennedy swinging liberal twice and conservative twice. In today's political world, of course, the candidates will probably be helped most by the decisions they opposed: nothing strengthens a call for new blood on the Court like giving rights to terrorists or declaring a sacred right to own a gun.

Protocol analysis of the decisions and their possible effects on the election below the fold.

In declining order of importance:

1. D.C. v. Heller
The decision: In a 5-4 opinion by Scalia, the Court for the first time interpreted the Second Amendment to guarantee an individual right to bear arms unlimited by the requirement of a state militia. The federal government cannot ban the ownership of any gun traditionally used for self-defense, and faces an as-yet-unspecified level of scrutiny on any restrictions it seeks to impose. Scalia carefully hedges that certain types of "unusual and dangerous" weapons may be banned, and that restrictions ownership by felons, minors, and the mentally handicapped would be allowed. For all its radical historical importance, the ruling itself is quite narrow: it explicitly leaves unaddressed the question of whether the Second Amendment is incorporated to apply against the states as well as the federal government.

The political fallout: McCain on offense, Obama on effective defense. Gun control has long been a hot button issue for the right, less so for the left. Obama's official position on gun control (stashed away in "Sportsmen" under "Additional Issues" on his website) has been consistent: he supports the individual right interpretation but leaves room for restrictions. He did say that he believed the D.C. handgun law was constitutional. McCain, despite his C+ from the NRA and staggering F- from Gun Owners of America, signed the amicus brief on Heller's behalf and has attacked Obama for flip-flopping on the issue.

Protocol Advantage?: Obama. His position was carefully tailored to blunt the impact of the decision: he knows it's political poison in these United States to oppose a Second Amendment right to bear arms. The decision will likely cement his support among those who fear a full-on right-wing Court under McCain, but his vaguely moderate gun control position won't turn off the great middle.


2. Boumediene v. Bush
The decision: In a 5-4 opinion by Kennedy, the Court held that all detainees held in Guantanamo Bay have the habeas corpus right to be informed of the charges against them and freed if evidence to support their detention is lacking. The Court, and not the Executive branch, is the final arbiter of "enemy combatant" determinations, Congressional legislation to the contrary notwithstanding. Protocol analysis here and here.

The political fallout: McCain responded cautiously at first, but then realized that Boumediene plays directly to his self-portrait as the only candidate serious about the War on "Terror" and called it "one of the worst decisions in the history of this country.” (Probably after an aide read it and found Scalia's gift: "[this decision] will almost certainly cause more Americans to be killed.") Obama's statement supporting the decision hit some strong notes--"this is an important step toward reestablishing our credibility as a nation committed to the rule of law, and rejecting a false choice between fighting terrorism and respecting habeas corpus"--which were then promptly undermined by some pure bullshit: "this Administration's position is not tough on terrorism." Really?

Protocol Advantage?: McCain. The hard right, already deeply suspicious of McCain's conservative bona fides, hates Kennedy and sees Boumediene as an unconscionable act of aid and comfort to the nation's enemies. In an election where McCain's success may depend on his ability to turn out the footsoldiers, his promise to appoint more Scalias and Alitos will only seem more vital.


3. Kennedy v. Louisiana
The decision: A 5-4 Court, again led by Kennedy (no relation, we hope), struck down a Lousiana statute allowing the death penalty for child rape. Interpreting the "cruel and unusual" language of the Eighth Amendment, the Court held that the ever-changing meaning of those words currently forbids the death penalty for any crime other than murder. Civilized people rejoiced; bloodthirsty revenge-mongers groused angrily.

The political fallout: Eh. Sad to say, the American public seems to have found its consensus on the death penalty--which Justice Kennedy, with his O'Connor-esque nose for public opinion, conveniently reflected in his decision. Obama made a lurch to the center by stating his public opposition to the holding, presciently warding off any gotcha debate questions along the lines of "so if your daughters were raped, you wouldn't call for the rapist's death, what kind of fuckin man ARE YOU?"

Protocol Advantage? Wash. The death penalty just isn't an issue either side gets too worked up about anymore. Obama's triangulation on the issue leaves him well-protected from those on the right who really really want to kill child rapists (and I mean, who kinda doesn't), and the left won't abandon him over it.


4. Davis v. Federal Election Commission
The decision: In yet another 5-4 opinion, this time by Alito, the Court struck down the Millionaire's Amendment of the McCain-Feingold campaign finance act. The provision allowed the opponent of a candidate who poured his own money into a race to receive extra donations to offset the millionaire's effect. Alito's opinion, mostly on First Amendment grounds, continued the Roberts Court's gutting of McCain's pet project by holding that the government cannot interfere with money-as-speech, even in the context of a public election.

The political fallout: Not a lot. The average voter doesn't get too worked up about complicated pieces of campaign finance reform legislation, and neither McCain nor Obama probably wants to play this up much. McCain's efforts to reform campaign finance outraged the right, who saw the law as an act of rank treason against Republican interests. If the Court had upheld the provision, he might have wanted to use it to play toward the middle's widespread disgust with corrupt politicians--but what's the point in highlighting a right-wing Court's full-on dissing of his law? And Obama won't want to remind voters that McCain made his bones in the public eye largely as a maverick outsider who vowed to clean up the system--and who passed the most comprehensive campaign finance bill since Watergate. Both candidates will probably let this one lie.

Protocol Advantage? Slight McCain--any play this decision will get among voters will only remind them of McCain's credentials as a reformer. The right will be pleased that the provision was struck down, and since they already hate him for the act in the first place, they're not gonna hate him more now.

Millionaires, child molesters, gun owners, and terrorists all have their appointed roles to fill under the October Protocol.

Read More...

General Bethlehem in The Times

Paul Villarreal, The Protocol's favorite delusional PUMA general, is at it again, getting his name dropped in the NYT as part of a new generation of freelance dirty tricksters. The Gray Lady soft-pedals his achievements, though, calling them a "harsh series of spots that attack Obama and make some claims that have been widely debunked." He is, in fact, batshit crazy:

My adversaries rightly fear me. They constantly seek to marginalize me and they expend vast amounts of energy trying to get others to ignore me. Because my foes cannot hope to compete with me head-to-head, theirs is a sound strategy and one I have become used to over the years. I imagine Custer, similarly, had a gameplan heading into Little Bighorn. This is how I feel about my opponents' tactics. I don't concern myself much with what they do and instead focus on what I need to execute vis-a-vis my own battle plans.
The labored military metaphors, the sense of destiny and entitlement, the evidence of a somewhat sad life spent dreaming of martial glory . . . you could only make this shit up in one of the worst movies of all time:

GEN. BETHLEHEM
If he wishes to rise above mere thuggery, a military commander must be classically educated. Philosophy, history. Even a sense of the dramatic. (a beat) Do you know what I did before the war? Do you think I was in the army? I sold copying machines. I was a salesman. The talent to lead men and devise and execute a battle plan were locked away inside me. If Nathan Holn hadn't come along, I'd still be selling copying machines. Can you imagine the wasted life? Can you imagine the magnitude of it? But war... War gives men like me a chance.
What's stranger, this clown making the Times or dozens of studio executives watching The Postman and saying, yeah, that's pretty good, audiences will love it? Only The Protocol knows.

The October Protocol hands out hope like candy from its pockets.

Read More...

Sunday, June 29, 2008

Virginia Polls: SUSA and Rasmussen 2008





Both SUSA and Rasmussen poll between 500-600 voters for each survey. Rasmussen polled likely voters in Virginia, while SUSA polled registered voters. If SUSA's more recent polls in other states are any indication, the next VA poll will also be of likely voters.

Read More...

Saturday, June 28, 2008

SUSA in Ohio



More exciting than Missouri, that's for sure. All polls surveyed between 527-629 voters. All were registered voter populations until the June poll which was likely voters.

Read More...

Friday, June 27, 2008

SUSA in Missouri



Not a whole lot of change over the course of the year. A lot depends on which way those Undecideds migrate.

(The sample size of most of the polls was between 536-562 voters. The exception is the May 18th poll which sampled 1523 voters. The first four polls surveyed registered voters and the last two surveyed likely voters.)

The Protocol will be keeping tabs on battleground state polling throughout the General Election.

Read More...

Thursday, June 26, 2008

This Week in Polling

Last week was a tough polling week for Sen. McCain. Rasmussen reported yesterday that from 6/13 to 6/20 on the spectrum of "Safe GOP" to "Safe Dem" they moved 8 states closer to the "Safe Dem" side. (Scroll down past Balance of Power chart for the History of Changes chart.) The only state that moved toward "Safe GOP" was Colorado on 6/20 moving from "Leans Dem" to "Toss Up" and that was merely a retraction of the 6/19 move from "Toss Up" to "Leans Dem."

It's only June (I mean, the Cubs still have the best record in baseball, so we know we have a ways to go till the fall), but look for Team McCain to adopt some changes in strategy.

There is no doubt about the Balance of Power within the Protocol.

Read More...

Wednesday, June 25, 2008

Barack Obama: So Deep Summer Tour '08

According to Ben Smith, Obama will be focusing his resources on campaigning in 18 states; 14 won by Bush in 2004 (AK, CO, FL, GA, IN, IA, MO, MT, NV, NM, NC, ND, OH, and VA) and 4 won by Kerry (MI, NH, PA, and WI). Consider this a memo to McCain from the Obama campaign stating, "Our fundraising jimmy runs deep, so deep, we put the Upper West to sleep." See map below.




In the following map, the more nuanced color gradient from blue to purple to red, reflects the 2004 margins of victory in each of these 18 states. The redder states indicate a larger margin of victory for Bush in 2004. The bluer states . . . well . . . don't look too hard, there aren't any among these 18 states, would've reflected large Kerry victories, while the purple color reflects state contests that were close in 2004.



What these maps show is that Obama's sizable war chest is allowing him to reach into traditionally Republican states and, at the very, very least, force McCain to play defense.

Sure, the usual suspects are on the list (Florida, Michigan, Ohio, and Pennsylvania), and changing demographics are pulling new states into play (Colorado, Nevada, and Virginia), but Montana, Indiana, Alaska, and North Dakota, states that Bush won by 20, 21, 25, and 27% respectively, really? . . . that's just an excuse to show off.

Obama (slowly tapping steepled fingers under chin): "David, have the Intermint print me another 10 million Obamabucks, I want to play in Ketchikan."

Plouffe (face buried in Blackberry, trying to sell Florida Election Commission on idea to switch to a caucus for the General, mouths to Obama) "Consider the memo sent."

Hope you like fly fishing, and Buffalo Burgers, Sen. McCain, because Obama and his Scrooge McDuck-like money bags of "Fuck you" cash are dropping into a fly-over zone near you.

The Protocol would like you to know that today was a good day.

Read More...